There was a moment in Game 1 of the NLWCS when Jhoan Duran had recorded five outs on 15 pitches where it was fair to wonder if Don Mattingly might try to use his closer for three innings to secure a postseason-opening victory over the Atlanta Braves.
Of course, that situation didn’t end up presenting itself. Michael Harris II started a two-out rally with an infield single, before Duran hit Ozzie Albies with a pitch. Duran then left a 99 mph fourseam fastball over the plate, with Austin Riley hitting a go-ahead three-home run in the bottom of the eighth that gave the Braves a 5-3 lead they wouldn’t relinquish.
Still, what does it say about the Phillies that their best path in the first game of the postseason was potentially to try to have their closer pitch for three innings? Mind you, this was after Duran appeared to be the only reliever the Phillies trusted — unless you count Ranger Suárez — when they lost the 2025 NLDS to the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2025. In 2024, the trio of Matt Strahm, Jeff Hoffman and Carlos Estévez melted down in the four-game NLDS loss to the New York Mets. And no one needs to be reminded about 2023.
The point is, this wasn’t just a one-year thing. The Phillies have been to the postseason five years in a row, and over the four most recent trips, their bullpen has been a major part of them coming up short of winning a World Series. It seems like an overcorrection might be in order.
President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski has had a storied career, so it’s hard to make generalizations about how he operates. But in recent history, he’s generally been hesitant to give long-term contracts to relievers.
When Dombrowski was leading the Boston Red Sox, they let Craig Kimbrel walk in free agency after the 2018 season. Granted, Kimbrel had run out of gas that postseason, with Chris Sale ultimately closing out a World Series win. Nonetheless, Kimbrel had been an All-Star in all three of his seasons with the Red Sox, recording 108 saves. This was an all-time great closer at the height of his powers, and Dombrowski didn’t re-sign him.
When Hoffman became a free agent after the 2024 season, the Phillies let him walk after he posted a 2.28 ERA in 122 games over two years with the club, the second of which he was an All-Star in. To be fair, Hoffman’s free agency was complicated, with the Baltimore Orioles and Atlanta Braves both backing out of deals where he would have become a starter because of physical concerns. But Hoffman ultimately landed what seemed to be a reasonable three-year/$33 million contract with the Toronto Blue Jays, a pact that included additional incentives. The Phillies had already pivoted, signing Jordan Romano to an ill-fated one-year/$8.5 million deal instead.
While Hoffman was still lingering on the free agent market but it was clear the Phillies were likely moving on, Dombrowski was asked how he feels generally about going beyond two years in reliever contracts, something he hadn’t done then, and still hasn’t in Philadelphia.
“Well, if Mariano Rivera was there, I’d be happy to go to four years,” Dombrowski joked.
“You know, there’s just a lot of inconsistencies in relievers in general. It’s more of a philosophical type of thing that some of the inconsistencies [make the Phillies hesitant]. But I have to tell you, it’s not a steadfast rule by any means. It just depends upon who the guys out there are at this time.”
And you know what? Dombrowski’s philosophy probably makes sense.
Hoffman had a rocky first season in Toronto, and ultimately blew a save in Game 7 of the World Series. He was traded to the Minnesota Twins before the 2026 trade deadline.
Brad Keller only got a two-year deal last offseason, and seemingly the Phillies were getting him at the front half of his prime after a breakout season against the Chicago Cubs. But the two-year/$22 million deal is likely going to be a wash. Keller posted a 4.02 ERA in 32 appearances before needing elbow reconstruction surgery that not only knocked him out for the rest of 2026, but may very well prevent him from pitching at all in 2027.
Free agency often is the last place you want to be trying to find relievers, particularly on multi-year deals.
And yet, you could argue the Phillies might not have a choice this offseason. They can’t count on Keller at all in 2027. Who knows if they’ll get anything out of Orion Kerkering, assuming he’s not traded. Tim Mayza is back on a one-year deal, but he’s not really a late-inning guy. Jonathan Bowlan should be a piece, but he definitely ran out of gas down the stretch. Alex McFarlane was very impressive in his first 19 MLB appearances, but are the Phillies going to go into 2027 counting on him to be their second most trusted reliever?
This is a bullpen that badly needs a second horse to pair with Duran, particularly one from the left side. Maybe they can find that on a one-year deal or in a trade, but they could just as easily find the next Romano or Brooks Raley.

The best way to try to overhaul the bullpen this offseason and turn it into a strength would be to sign Adrian Morejon. Over the last two seasons, Morejon has a 2.48 ERA and 2.33 FIP across 151 appearances for the San Diego Padres. Over that period, his 5.1 WAR is third among all relievers, trailing only teammate Mason Miller and Cade Smith of the Cleveland Guardians. Morejon — who will turn 28 in February — would be the perfect eighth-inning option for the Phillies, while also giving them insurance at closer if Jhoan Duran leaves in free agency next winter.
It won’t be cheap to sign Morejon. Over on Bleacher Report, I projected that Morejon will land a four-year/$80 million deal. In addition to that, Morejon received a qualifying offer from the Padres. If the Phillies sign him, they’ll have to give up second- and fifth-round picks in the 2027 MLB Draft, along with $1 million in international bonus pool money. Signing Morejon would likely mean the Phillies don’t land another qualified free agent, such as Seiya Suzuki or Randy Arozarena.
There’s also — as the Phillies have found out with contracts given to David Robertson and Keller — health risk with signing relievers to multi-year deals. Morejon took down two innings in Game 1 of the NLWCS against the Milwaukee Brewers. But he wasn’t available over the final three games of the series because of “stickiness” in his shoulder. Any team signing Morejon is going to need to feel like that was just him being tired, as opposed to an indication of a bigger issue.
There’s plenty of reasons you can talk yourself out of signing Morejon, and the guess here is that Dombrowski and the Phillies ultimately won’t sign him.
Without making this type of investment, though, they run the risk of showing up next postseason without any reliable relievers beyond Duran. We’ll see what scenario scares them more.
Read More Phillies Content From OnPattison
- We think we’ve figured out who bought the ‘cursed’ Ben Simmons/Nick Castellanos house
- What would the Phillies have to give up to sign free agent with qualifying offer?
- Seiya Suzuki or Randy Arozarena, who would be a better fit for Phillies?
- The Phillies didn’t extend a qualifying offer to Alec Bohm
- Japanese MVP that Phillies have been linked to officially posted
- What free-agent options do Phillies have to upgrade backup catcher?
- Is Luis Arraez a fit for the 2027 Phillies?
- Here’s the Phillies record by uniform in 2026
- Want the Phillies to play more like Brewers and Rays? Unlocking Justin Crawford will be key
- If Trea Turner doesn’t convince Phillies to keep him at SS, will he remain an infielder?

