Back in April, we learned that a Moorestown, New Jersey mansion that had previously been home to both Ben Simmons and Nick Castellanos had sold for $4.89 million.

Given the terms that both Simmons and Castellanos left Philadelphia on, the house has become of interest to Philadelphia sports fans because there’s a running bit about it being cursed. That made it unsurprising when the identity of the new buyer of the home wasn’t revealed. However, the listing agent for the home, Naoji Moriuchi, did give an interesting quote to Ryan Mulligan of The Philadelphia Business Journal at the time:

“We actually don’t know for certain who the person that bought it was, so there’s still this mystery around who is this buyer,” Moriuchi said, adding that “we do think that it is another athlete.”

All that was known at the time is the home was purchased by “Half Dozen LLC.” No. 6 is retired by the Sixers for Julius Erving, while the Phillies have had it iced for a decade now for Ryan Howard. The only two active players who wear No. 6 in Philadelphia are DeVonta Smith with the Eagles and Travis Sanheim with the Flyers. No evidence connected Erving, Howard, Smith, or Sanheim to the house, and short of showing up and knocking on the front door, there didn’t seem to be any real way to confirm who lived there.

But there’s been a new development that doesn’t give a definite answer, but certainly leads to some dot connecting.

Screenshot 2026 11 03 at 1.02.44 PM
(Zillow)

There’s a current Zillow listing at 511 Westminster Ave in Haddonfield, NJ. Billed as “a stunning Haddonfield home” that provides “timeless farmhouse elegance,” it was purchased in August of 2019 for $2.1 million. It’s pretty well established at this point that the buyer of that house was Bryce Harper:

This house is now listed at $4.5 million, so Bryce and his wife Kayla — who have had four children since moving into the home — would be getting quite the return on investment.

So what does this mean? Well, the listing agent for the house is Melissa Casterioto of Weichert Realtors in Moorestown. Not only is the Simmons/Castellanos home in Moorestown, but Philly Voice‘s Michael Tanenbaum noted that when the “cursed” house sold, the agent representing Half Dozen LLC was … Melissa Casterioto.

To make things even more interesting, Melissa is married to Greg Casterioto, who is currently the vice president of public relations for Perfect Game. Previously, Casterioto worked for the Phillies for more than 22 years, including serving as the director of communications for the Phillies from January of 2009 until October of 2021. So he was the point person for baseball communications during Harper’s first three seasons on the Phillies.

Calls to Melissa’s listed cell and office number were not answered, nor was a text returned.

The only missing piece of information would be trying to understand the meaning behind the name Half Dozen LLC. Harper obviously does not wear No. 6. He’s worn No. 3 since joining the Phillies, after donning No. 34 in his seven years with the Washington Nationals. However, if you add up Bryce, Kayla and their four kids, it equals a half dozen. The couple was adamant in an interview with Kristin Cavallari published in September that they don’t plan to have any more children:

So there’s our theory. The Harper Family — which has grown exponentially since coming to Philadelphia — purchased the Moorestown house from his former teammate earlier this year, and are now selling their original in-season home. If they get their desired asking price of $4.5 million, it will come close to covering the $4.89 million spent on the new home, assuming that is indeed what happened.

As long as you don’t believe in curses, there’s a lot to like about the Moorestown place. You can see below what it looked like at the time that Simmons was selling the place back in October of 2021:

Read More Phillies Content From OnPattison

  1. What would the Phillies have to give up to sign free agent with qualifying offer?
  2. Seiya Suzuki or Randy Arozarena, who would be a better fit for Phillies?
  3. The Phillies didn’t extend a qualifying offer to Alec Bohm
  4. Japanese MVP that Phillies have been linked to officially posted
  5. What free-agent options do Phillies have to upgrade backup catcher?
  6. Is Luis Arraez a fit for the 2027 Phillies?
  7. Here’s the Phillies record by uniform in 2026
  8. Want the Phillies to play more like Brewers and Rays? Unlocking Justin Crawford will be key
  9. If Trea Turner doesn’t convince Phillies to keep him at SS, will he remain an infielder?
  10. What Jhoan Duran being repped by Scott Boras means for his future with Phillies