Should teachers be required to use students’ preferred pronouns? Should guidance counselors and teachers keep students’ preferred names and pronouns secret from their parents? 

After receiving a demand letter from lawyers at the civil rights firms Independence Law Center and Alliance Defending Freedom, a Chester County school district agreed to end its gender transition policies. 

The letter, on behalf of a staff member at the Brandywine Virtual Academy, part of Chester County Intermediate Unit 24, noted that the “U.S. Supreme Court ruled that California school policies that prohibited schools from disclosing a child’s gender transitioning activity to parents without the child’s consent likely violate the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment and the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.” 

The district policy had mandated “Intermediate Unit personnel should not disclose information that may reveal a student’s transgender status or gender nonconforming presentation to others, including the student’s parents/guardians and/or other Intermediate Unit personnel, unless legally required to do so or unless the student has authorized such disclosure,” the letter said, quoting the district’s policies.

Further, the district threatened to take disciplinary action against personnel who didn’t comply with this policy. 

The demand letter said that telling staff only to use the students’ preferred pronouns violates their First Amendment rights to free speech and religion. And it interferes with parental rights to know what is going on with their child.

“Multiple studies have found that the vast majority of children (80–90%) who experience feelings of discomfort with their sex, including gender dysphoria, ultimately ‘desist,’ finding comfort with their sex; that is, unless they take affirmative steps to live inconsistently with their sex. Because messages from others help to form a child’s identity, many psychiatric professionals believe that taking these “transitioning” steps can become self-reinforcing, setting children down a path with lifelong consequences,” the letter said. 

The district’s policy on students with gender dysphoria takes “this life-altering decision out of parents’ hands–and knowledge–and places it with educators,” the letter said. 

They also cited a 2025 case that’s out of Maryland where the high court upheld parents’ rights to opt their elementary school children out of instruction with LGBT themes, as well as the March 2026 case from California.  

As well as rescinding the policy [103.2], the letter demanded that the district inform teachers in writing of the change. 

“These policies are quite common. And in many schools without a written policy, it’s common practice,” said Randall Wenger, chief counsel at Independence Law Center. “However, the Supreme Court has now weighed in. As we explained in our demand letter, the Supreme Court’s March 2026 Order in Mirabelli reinstated an injunction against California policies that had required schools to facilitate secret gender transition plans. The Court’s Order reinforced the fundamental principle that schools cannot cut parents out of major decisions concerning the upbringing and care of their children.”

The group Parents Defending Education lists numerous Pennsylvania school districts with similar policies regarding students with gender dysphoria.  The local districts include: Abington, Bristol Borough, Cheltenham, Colonial, Great Valley,  Lower Merion, Marple-Newtown, New Hope-Solebury, Penn-Delco, Pennsbury, Philadelphia, Radnor, Rose Tree Media, Haverford, Jenkintown, Springfield [Montgomery County], Upper Darby, Upper Moreland, Wallingford-Swarthmore, and Wissahickon. 

A 2023 poll by the same group found that 71% of voters support legislation to require schools to tell parents if their children want to transition to another gender, rather than keeping it secret. 

The federal government has also taken steps to stop this practice. 

President Trump’s 2025 executive order directed federal agencies to address federal funding used to support the social transition of minors, including deliberately concealing that transition from parents. The federal Department of Education has since made these secrecy policies an enforcement priority under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), concluding in several cases that policies preventing parents from accessing records concerning a child’s social transition violate federal law. 

A spokesperson for the Chester County Intermediate Unit could not immediately be reached for comment.