A Common Pleas Court judge made it clear that ignoring the Sunshine Act is not an option.
The Republican Committee of Chester County, committeepeople Felice Fein, Jeanne Locastro, Becky McCarron, and Kim Schaeffer, had filed a request for an injunction in 2024 after county election officials suddenly changed the rules.
The committeepeople, who were also running for their office, were told they could no longer work as poll watchers at their precincts. The county Board of Elections made this change outside public view, in violation of the Sunshine Act, Berks County Judge Jeffrey K. Specher, now retired, found.
Specher ordered the county to pay the RCCC $5,000 in legal fees. He also enjoined the county from further violations of the Sunshine Act.
“The public had no way of commenting or even knowing about it,” said Fein, about the changes.
The other change that county officials made behind closed doors was to allow a worker at a long-term care facility in West Goshen to collect ballots for numerous patients.
“The county made that determination privately,” Fein said.
The RCCC had discovered that one nursing home employee was acting as an agent for at least 10 residents. The RCCC did not challenge the ballots but, rather, challenged the county’s lack of compliance with the Sunshine Act, which requires official business to be conducted in public, with prior notice and the opportunity for members of the public to comment. The county had claimed that it held a public hearing, but the litigation process revealed that it did not.
“This is a great win for the RCC. However, I believe it will probably be short-lived. I don’t think a check will be coming out of the Chester County Treasurer’s Office,” Fein said.
Dolores Troiani, the solicitor for the RCCC, who handled the litigation, said ordering the county to pay legal fees is rare and “it’s more than a sanction.”
“It might be a hollow victory,” Troiani said. “They might appeal. It would cost them more than $5,000 for them to appeal.”
Indeed, Andrew Kreider, a spokesman for the county, told Broad + Liberty that the county has appealed.
“As a matter of policy, the county does not comment on pending or ongoing litigation,” he said.
Chester County is using an outside law firm, Dilworth Paxson, to handle the case, rather than its one solicitor.
Neither Fein nor Troiani were surprised by the county’s move.
Fein said the county always appeals when it loses since it has deep, taxpayer-funded pockets, while residents must pay out of their own wallets.
“It’s lawfare,” she said.
In a related matter, on Sept. 16 the county Board of Elections approved two new unmanned drop boxes, despite numerous residents’ objections and a previous court order settling a 2022 case. Minority County Commissioner Eric Roe also objected.
“These meetings are a joke,” said Troiani. “They don’t answer [the public] and do what they want to do in private.”
In that case, a judge had memorialized a settlement where the county agreed to only use ballot boxes where someone is watching. Otherwise, the ballot boxes were to be kept locked.
“This was part of an agreement,” Troiani said.
In the 2022 case, the plaintiffs presented ample evidence of ballot box stuffing, including 300 still photos of people putting multiple ballots in a ballot box, Troiani said. They even showed one person filling out multiple ballots before putting them into the drop box.
Kreider did not respond when asked what had changed from 2022 to 2026 that would cause the Board of Elections to ignore the prior agreement and permit unmonitored ballot boxes.

