While quite a bit of uncertainty remains in the outfield, the infield picture for the Phillies might not be as complicated as we thought entering the winter.
Alec Bohm, Luis Arraez and Edmundo Sosa are all free agents, which seemingly created a lot of instability in the infield for the Phillies this offseason. It appears as though Bohm is being courted by both New York teams. Jon Heyman of The New York Post says that the Yankees have checked in with a slew of infielders, including Arraez. Sosa could potentially seek a larger role — on a multi-year deal — which would likely push him out of Philly. There’s a distinct possibility that all three are playing elsewhere next season.
Based on what president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said at the GM meetings this week in Las Vegas, the Phillies might already have an idea of what their Opening Day infield will look like without any of Bohm, Arraez and Sosa.

First Base
Even if both Kyle Schwarber and J.T. Realmuto could see more time at first base next season, Bryce Harper figures to get the overwhelming majority of the reps at first base in 2027.
Harper made clear when he moved back to right field upon the acquisition of Arraez that he expected to return to first base in 2027. Harper posted minus-five defensive runs saved and minus-three outs above average in 363 2/3 innings in right field, although he clearly was being overly cautious in his first outfield action since 2022. With the exception of one play in Game 2 of the NLWCS, Harper was fine in right field. When the trade deadline rolls around, there will be inevitable discussion about the two-time NL MVP shifting back to the outfield.
For the time being, though, Harper is back at first base. New infield coach Carlos Mendoza will be tasked with trying to get Harper back on track defensively. He had zero defensive runs saved and minus-five outs above average across 923 2/3 innings at first base last year. There were more than a few occasions where he got to a ball and seemed to just dive over it. Harper did turn 34 in October, but as recently as 2024, he had five DRS and eight OAA at first base. With some extra DH and off days in 2027, Harper’s defensive metrics should improve.

Third Base
Dombrowski sure made it sound this week like top prospect Aidan Miller is likely to be part of the Opening Day roster in some form.
“He’s not being anointed a position, but I think he has a heck of a chance to make our club in the spring,” Dombrowski said, per Jim Salisbury of NBC Sports Philadelphia. “I think he has the capabilities. And it’s not just me. Anybody that’s seen him, including people from other organizations, agree. You still have to earn the spot, and I’m hoping – I’m not giving it to him – but I’m hoping he does.”
A back injury prevented Miller from playing a role for the Phillies in 2026, as he wound up appearing in just four regular-season minor league games in 2026. However, he got some at-bats in the Arizona Fall League, hitting .327 in 52 at-bats. Granted, the pitching is notoriously not great, but the biggest thing is that Miller made it through healthy. That’s going to be the concern with him moving forward.
There is an argument to be made that the former first-round pick needs some at-bats at Triple-A before making his Major League Debut. Since he’s not on the 40-man roster, he may be able to get those with the IronPigs in April (at least) unless the new MLB collective bargaining agreement is reached quicker than most think it will be. Miller will turn 23 on June 9. The MLB season might be starting around that time, at which point Miller could get the call-up.
He’s a natural shortstop, but third base is where the Phillies have a need. It’s where he played in the AFL. In the best-case scenario, Miller will add an impact right-handed bat to the lineup, while also combining with Justin Crawford to give the Phillies consistent basestealing attempts. He just has to stay healthy.

Second Base
Bryson Stott held his own in 367 1/3 innings at third base after the Arraez trade, posting minus-one DRS and one OAA at the hot corner. The Phillies would likely be comfortable with him playing third base full time.
Stott’s natural position is shortstop, for whatever it’s worth. He could play there if the Phillies need him to, although that wouldn’t seem to be their best alignment. Stott hasn’t played more than 100 innings at shortstop since his rookie season of 2022, which he finished with minus-five DRS and minus-three OAA.
The guess here is that Stott will return to second base to start his contract year. The top defensive metrics were divided on him last year, as he posted minus-nine DRS at second base, but eight OAA. The metrics aren’t perfect. Sometimes, Harper ranged too far over to second base, making Stott’s life more difficult. But Stott could also benefit from a new voice in Mendoza.
Now 29, Stott’s biggest test in his contract year is going to be whether he can put together a full season at the plate. Everyone involved seems to think there’s more there.

Shortstop
You may not like it, but the Phillies are giving Trea Turner one last chance to show that he can continue to play shortstop. Particularly if there’s a shortened Spring Training or Summer Camp, it’s hard to imagine what could happen before the regular season to get the Phillies to pull the plug on Turner at shortstop before Opening Day.
Dombrowski said this week that Turner isn’t practicing any other positions. That leads you to believe that not only will he begin the season at shortstop, but that it’s much more likely he’ll shift to second base (where he has relatively recent experience at) than the outfield if the Phillies decide his time at his preferred position is up.
The Phillies will be able to pivot if they have to, though. Miller and Stott are natural shortstops. Bryan Rincon, a 22-year-old shortstop, hit 26 home runs for Double-A Reading this past season. Whether it’s Ha-Seong Kim or someone else, the Phillies will have another bench option capable of playing shortstop. A midseason pivot in 2026 wasn’t seriously considered. If Mendoza can’t help Turner drastically improve in 2027, it will be.
Read More Phillies Content From OnPattison
- Will Dave Dombrowski be desperate enough to give huge contract to a reliever?
- Japanese outlet says Phillies are interested in Teruaki Sato
- Report: Trea Turner, Brandon Marsh ‘available’; Bryce Harper, Kyle Schwarber won’t be moved
- Phillies reportedly interested in versatile veteran infielder
- If not Suzuki or Arozarena, these are the other free agent outfield options for Phillies to consider
- We think we’ve figured out who bought the ‘cursed’ Ben Simmons/Nick Castellanos house
- What would the Phillies have to give up to sign free agent with qualifying offer?
- Seiya Suzuki or Randy Arozarena, who would be a better fit for Phillies?
- What free-agent options do Phillies have to upgrade backup catcher?
- Here’s the Phillies record by uniform in 2026

