Based on what Dave Dombrowski said in his year-end press conference, it appears that J.T. Realmuto finally realizes he could benefit from a lighter workload.

For the eighth time in his career, Realmuto caught over 1,000 innings in 2026. But while Realmuto’s durability is admirable, he’s at the point in his career where he’s delivering diminishing returns with that large of a workload. The long-time Phillies backstop finished the season with minus-five defensive runs saved, zero framing runs and a 65 OPS+ (100 is league average).

It’s certainly fair to wonder if the Phillies bid against themselves by re-signing Realmuto for three years and $45 million last offseason (and if there was serious competition, perhaps they should have let him walk). But Realmuto is going to be the starting catcher for the next two seasons, and the Phillies evidently realize they need to A) lessen his workload and B) get better production from the backup catcher.

Despite great work with Aaron Nola in the second half of the season, the Phillies designated Garrett Stubbs for assignment last week, with the 33-year-old planning to elect free agency if he clears waivers.

Interestingly, Dombrowski noted that “we do emphasize defense more in our catching position than we do offense.” Well, Rafael Marchán is arbitration eligible, and he finished 2026 with five defensive runs saved and a six fielding run value. He’s a really good defender. The problem is he’s hit .158 in 196 at-bats since the start of the 2025 season. Perhaps Marchán — who is out of minor-league options — will be tendered a contract and be in camp with the Phillies, but it’s hard to imagine opening 2027 with him as Realmuto’s primary backup.

So what options will the Phillies have in free agency? Let’s take a look.

2026 09 01T013944Z 891718605 MT1USATODAY29706829 RTRMADP 3 MLB DETROIT TIGERS AT MINNESOTA TWINS
Aug 31, 2026; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers (27) celebrates hitting a three run home run against the Detroit Tigers in the fifth inning at Target Field. Mandatory Credit: Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images

Ryan Jeffers

Jeffers is probably the best catcher available this offseason, having homered 14 times and posted an .814 OPS for the Minnesota Twins this past year. He had a much more modest workload than Realmuto, catching 674 1/3 innings. But the 29-year-old will definitely get a multi-year deal to start somewhere next year.

Matt Gelb of The Athletic reported last January that the Phillies had considered Jeffers as a trade target when Realmuto was a free agent. A year later, that seems like it would have been a better option.

2026 10 01T025718Z 382970670 MT1USATODAY29963530 RTRMADP 3 MLB WILDCARD CHICAGO CUBS AT SAN DIEGO PADRES
Sep 30, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; Chicago Cubs catcher Carson Kelly (15) looks on after hitting a single in the third inning against the San Diego Padres during game two of the Wildcard round for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images

Carson Kelly

The 32-year-old caught 848 1/3 innings for the Chicago Cubs in 2026. He’s coming off of a campaign where he posted a .713 OPS, 99 points higher than Realmuto. He’s not coming to Philadelphia to back up Realmuto.

2026 07 22T004738Z 831893823 MT1USATODAY29425787 RTRMADP 3 MLB MINNESOTA TWINS AT CLEVELAND GUARDIANS
Jul 21, 2026; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Cleveland Guardians catcher Austin Hedges (27) celebrates after hitting a sacrifice fly during the sixth inning against the Minnesota Twins at Progressive Field. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-Imagn Images

Austin Hedges

Back in February of 2015, Bob Nightengale of USA Today reported that the Phillies had passed on an offer for ace Cole Hamels that would have allowed them to acquire a pair of prospects from the San Diego Padres: Hunter Renfroe and Austin Hedges. In hindsight, that package would have been better than the one the Phillies ultimately got from the Texas Rangers in July of 2015, a deal led by Jorge Alfaro, Nick Williams, Jake Thompson and Jerad Eickhoff.

Hedges, now 34, hasn’t typically been much of an offensive force. He did homer seven times and post a .702 OPS for the Cleveland Guardians this season, but is a career .190 hitter with a .569 OPS. But the reason he’s played in the league for 12 years is that he has 93 career defensive runs saved. It should be noted that he had minus-four DRS in 601 2/3 innings for the Guards this past year, but he’s mostly been an excellent backstop in his career.

Hedges may ultimately be looking for a larger role than what the Phillies have to offer. But if the Phillies can land him, he might be the best of the realistic options.

2026 07 25T080614Z 1131427926 MT1USATODAY29448127 RTRMADP 3 MLB HOUSTON ASTROS AT TEXAS RANGERS
Jul 11, 2026; Arlington, Texas, USA; Houston Astros catcher Christian Vazquez (2) walks to the on deck circle during the game between the Rangers and the Astros at Globe Life Field. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images

Christian Vázquez is 36 years old, which might be a dealbreaker. But as you’ll see on this list, there’s not a ton of young talented catchers available.

Vázquez won a World Series with Dombrowski and the Boston Red Sox in 2018, and then was on the Astros team that beat the Phillies in the 2022 Fall Classic. He hit just .207 with a .583 OPS in his second go-round with the Astros in 2026, but with six defensive runs saved and a three fielding run value, he would check the box of being able to handle the position on days where Realmuto is off.

2025 07 31T021549Z 1856808279 MT1USATODAY26744555 RTRMADP 3 MLB TEXAS RANGERS AT LOS ANGELES ANGELS
Jul 30, 2025; Anaheim, California, USA; Texas Rangers designated hitter Kyle Higashioka (11) runs after hitting a triple against the Los Angeles Angels during the second inning at Angel Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Gary A. Vasquez-Imagn Images

Kyle Higashioka

In 165 at-bats for the Texas Rangers last season, Higashioka homered seven times and posted a .676 OPS. He would be a downgrade from Marchán behind the plate, as he posted minus-two defensive runs saved and a minus-four fielding run value in 2026. Is his bat enough of an upgrade over Marchán to deal with some of his defensive shortcomings? Plus, would the Phillies really sign another 36-year-old catcher?

2026 09 01T053638Z 1305239509 MT1USATODAY29707671 RTRMADP 3 MLB SAN DIEGO PADRES AT CINCINNATI REDS
Aug 31, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Reds catcher Tyler Stephenson (37) catches a ball tossed by umpire D.J. Reyburn (17), during the game against the San Diego Padres at Great American Ball Park. Mandatory Credit: Aaron Doster-Imagn Images

Tyler Stephenson

We’re mentioning Stephenson here because he’s a free agent. But the 30-year-old has gotten poor defensive marks for most of his career, and with a .757 OPS over seven seasons with the Cincinnati Reds, he’s going to be looking for a larger role than the Phillies have to offer.

2026 07 28T032149Z 325293481 MT1USATODAY29462521 RTRMADP 3 MLB ATHLETICS AT ARIZONA DIAMONDBACKS
Jul 21, 2026; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks catcher James McCann against the Athletics at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

James McCann

Remember this graphic?

Since sny tweeted this image in december 2020 j t realmuto v0 SFb7AdAfL8kGy4uyOQ emVFey1h7oUZju92Ca2o4LEU

As funny it would be for these two to end up as teammates, it would give the Phillies a very old catching tandem. McCann is a veteran of 13 seasons, and will play next season at 37 years old.

With that said … he’s posted a 110 OPS+ as the backup for the Arizona Diamondbacks over the past two seasons, so don’t completely rule it out.

Read More Phillies Content From OnPattison

  1. Seiya Suzuki or Randy Arozarena, who would be a better fit for Phillies?
  2. Is Luis Arraez a fit for the 2027 Phillies?
  3. It doesn’t make sense for Phillies to extend qualifying offer to Alec Bohm
  4. Here’s the Phillies record by uniform in 2026
  5. Want the Phillies to play more like Brewers and Rays? Unlocking Justin Crawford will be key
  6. If Trea Turner doesn’t convince Phillies to keep him at SS, will he remain an infielder?
  7. What Jhoan Duran being repped by Scott Boras means for his future with Phillies
  8. Ian Happ might be most logical target in free agency for Phillies to upgrade outfield
  9. Phillies continue to be linked to Japanese Triple Crown winner
  10. Don Mattingly responds to perception he was fallback option for Phillies