Chester County Commissioner Eric Roe is crying foul over the plan from the Board of Elections to add three more drop boxes, which would be unmanned. 

To end litigation in 2022, Chester County, through its attorney, agreed that all of its drop boxes would be manned and locked when not manned. 

“Counsel committed to having no unmanned ballot drop boxes. Further, all drop boxes will be capable of receiving drop ballots only during specified periods of time when those boxes are monitored by paid employees of the Board. When not monitored, the boxes will be locked,” a footnote in an order by Common Pleas Judge William P. Mahon said. 

On Facebook, Roe said the election board “will hold a hastily scheduled voting meeting to consider a measure to create three unmanned, overnight drop boxes for this year’s election. This is a terrible idea that will lead to voters breaking Pennsylvania election law, knowingly or unknowingly,” he said. 

State law requires people to place only their own ballot in a drop box. It does not allow someone else to drop off someone’s ballot except for “narrow criteria,” such as when the voter is physically disabled. 

“As you can imagine, several years ago, people were dropping off stacks of ballots at Chester County’s drop boxes anyway. Whether knowingly or unknowingly, it was a violation of state election law. Hundreds of instances of it have been documented. Many photographs were taken proving it. A lawsuit was even filed to get the Chester County election board to staff its drop boxes with county employees to ensure that election laws be followed correctly. Then, the election board changed its policy to require drop boxes to be staffed. The judge was happy with the outcome, and the lawsuit was voluntarily withdrawn because of this change in policy.”

But the new unmanned drop boxes would be available to use at night, watched only by cameras. 

“If this measure passes next week, it will invite unlawful activity. I’m all for giving voters the tools to cast their votes, but we know from past experience that these 24/7 drop boxes will lead to unlawful conduct. This is a huge and avoidable mistake,” said Roe.

Roe, a former state representative who is Chester County’s Republican minority commissioner, told Broad + Liberty, “I don’t make state laws anymore, like I did when I was a state representative. As a county commissioner, I execute the laws handed down to me from the state. Those laws must be followed. They’re not optional. The law says that voters may only return their own ballots. As a commissioner, I can’t set policies that I know from past experience will result in violations of state election law. I have personally reviewed hundreds of photographs of people returning multiple ballots at a time. With that knowledge, I cannot eliminate the safeguards that were put in place to prevent those violations of state law. Under no circumstances should Chester County’s drop boxes be unstaffed.” 

The county’s current rules also specify that drop boxes be manned. 

Asked to comment, Andrew Kreider, a spokesman for the county, gave only this response: “The Chester County Board of Elections will meet on September 16. The agenda for this meeting will be posted at least 24 hours in advance.”

The Election Board meeting is set for Sept. 16 at 10:30 a.m., following the Board of Commissioners and Salary Board meetings, on the 6th floor of 313 West Market Street in West Chester. 

Roe requested on Facebook that members of the public attend to show their opposition to unmanned ballot boxes.